In
accordance with the book of
Ramón Pérez, "The Village Speaks" (pp 29-30) ("El Pueblo
Habla" (pp 37-38), which is the most comprehensive recompilation of the
Garabandal events: on January 1, 1965 the Virgin Mary revealed,
for the first time ever and
to Conchita alone, while at the Pines, the information regarding the
Warning. During the same
apparition the Virgin Mary revealed the nature
of the
Chastisement.
The seriousness of this anomaly is that the only other reported
communications between the Virgin Mary and any of the visionaries
after
January 1st, 1965, were as follows:
+ On June 18, 1965, St. Michael the
Archangel delivers the final message from the Virgin Mary to Conchita.
+ On October 24, 1965, Mari Loli has a locution from the Virgin
Mary letting her know that she will have many doubts as to what she saw
and heard.
+ On November 13, 1965, the Virgin Mary appears to Conchita
for the last time.
Where then did Mari Loli and Jacinta get the information about the
Warning? The only value that
may be placed in their comments about the
Warning - regardless of their
claims - would be that of hearsay and not
that of primary witnesses. We therefore recommend that they be ignored
unless someone, with greater historical authority than Ramón
Pérez, can prove to us otherwise.